Back to Blog

How to Verify a Signature in a Wrong Way — The AssociationNFT Case

Code Auditing
April 21, 2022
Image: Raymond Clarke/Flickr
Image: Raymond Clarke/Flickr

The Association NFT is a NBA launched NFT. However, we find the NFT sale contract has a serious vulnerability which allows an attacker to mint a large number NFTs, without paying any Tokens.

The root cause of the vulnerability is the incorrect use of signature verification. Basically, the contract fails to ensure that the signature can only be used by the user (and only the user) once. In this case, the attacker can reuse a privileged user’s signature and mint tokens to him/herself.

We can see that in the verify function, there is no sender's address in the signature. Besides, there is no mechanism to include a nonce to ensure that the signature can only be used once. These security requirements are the basic knowledge in the software security class.

We are surprised that how such a vulnerability can exist in a popular NFT project. The whole community needs to pay more attention to the security of the contract.

About BlockSec

BlockSec is a pioneering blockchain security company established in 2021 by a group of globally distinguished security experts. The company is committed to enhancing security and usability for the emerging Web3 world in order to facilitate its mass adoption. To this end, BlockSec provides smart contract and EVM chain security auditing services, the Phalcon platform for security development and blocking threats proactively, the MetaSleuth platform for fund tracking and investigation, and MetaSuites extension for web3 builders surfing efficiently in the crypto world.

To date, the company has served over 300 esteemed clients such as MetaMask, Uniswap Foundation, Compound, Forta, and PancakeSwap, and received tens of millions of US dollars in two rounds of financing from preeminent investors, including Matrix Partners, Vitalbridge Capital, and Fenbushi Capital.

Official website: https://blocksec.com/

Official Twitter account: https://twitter.com/BlockSecTeam

Sign up for the latest updates
Beyond Secure Storage, Part 2: Implementing Wallet Cryptography Securely
Security Insights

Beyond Secure Storage, Part 2: Implementing Wallet Cryptography Securely

Can an attacker recover a private key without reading its protected copy? Part 2 of Beyond Secure Storage examines six incidents in which weak randomness, entropy loss, or signing nonce flaws made keys predictable or recoverable. It derives implementation requirements for key generation and signing, then explains how payment institutions can assess them through code review and testing of the deployed system.

Beyond Secure Storage, Part 1: Designing Secure Payment and Signing Workflows
Security Insights

Beyond Secure Storage, Part 1: Designing Secure Payment and Signing Workflows

How can an unauthorized operation obtain a valid signature without the attacker stealing the private key? Part 1 of Beyond Secure Storage uses incidents including Bitget, Bybit and Binance to examine authorization failures across payment requests, transaction construction, signing, execution and settlement. It derives design principles for preventing unauthorized operations and limiting losses, then explains how reviews, audits, penetration tests and exercises can verify those protections.

NEAR Intents Exploit: Refund Flaw and Security Lessons
Security Insights

NEAR Intents Exploit: Refund Flaw and Security Lessons

The NEAR Intents exploit used oversized refund events to preserve internal balances after the deposited assets were returned. This analysis reconstructs the receipt flow and seven BNB Chain withdrawals totaling 3,865,021 USDT, distinguishes those outflows from the project's reported full recovery, and outlines security considerations for developing and auditing NEAR smart contracts.

Best Security Auditor for Web3

Validate design, code, and business logic before launch. Aligned with the highest industry security standards.

BlockSec Audit
How to Verify a Signature in a Wrong Way — The AssociationNFT Case